There are so many factors to consider when getting a mattress for your newborn. Will it be too soft, too hard, what’s it made of, is anything toxic in it…? The worries are endless. Luckily, plenty of other people have done the work of testing and research, so you don’t have to! Here are Amazon’s best picks for newborn mattresses.
In this review:
At a Glance: Our Top Picks
Sealy Flex Cool 2-Stag Waterproof Airy Dual Firmness Toddler & Baby Crib Mattress
1. Graco Premium Toddler Mattress and Foam Crib
The Graco Premium features premium airflow, providing ideal firmness for baby’s delicate bones. A polyester cover functions as a moisture barrier, and it also includes a fire barrier and a polyurethane foam core. It conveniently ships in a box and fits any standard full-size crib/toddler bed. This mattress also comes with a removable, water-resistant, washable outer cover. This is so convenient for those little accidents your baby may have! Finally, and maybe most importantly, it is Greenguard Gold certified, meaning it’s free of any harmful chemicals.
Features
- Airflow
- Ideal firmness
- Water-resistant, washable cover
- Greenguard Gold certified
Information
This is a fallback generated paragraph due to an invalid API response.
See price
2. Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams White Crib & Toddler Bed
Safety 1st’s mattress is great because it is lightweight and durable. It has a vinyl outer cover that is water-resistant and can be wiped clean, which is perfect for a newborn. It has a weight limit of 50lb and a 10-year warranty, so it will definitely cover the length of time you need it for! This mattress has Greenguard Gold certification, which promises low chemical emissions into the air during usage. This brand received the Women’s Choice Award for America’s Most Recommended brand of crib and toddler mattress. This mattress is a great choice for any family!
Features
- Lightweight
- Vinyl cover
- 10-year warranty
- Women’s Choice Award
- Greenguard Gold certification
Information
3. Delta Children Twinkle Stars Fiber Core Crib and Toddler Mattress
This baby mattress features a thermo-bonded polyester fiber core. It’s very lightweight at only 9 lbs, making for easy moving and rotating. Square corners ensure a secure fit inside the crib. It has a durable vinyl cover, so it’s easy to clean. It’s Goldguard certified, which means it contains no toxic chemicals. It also comes with a 7-year limited warranty that is sure to cover any issues.
Features
- Thermo-bonded polyester fiber core
- Square corners
- Durable vinyl cover
- Greenguard Gold certified
Information
4. Sealy Flex Cool 2-Stag Waterproof Airy Dual Firmness Toddler & Baby Crib Mattress
The Sealy Flex is a little pricier than the others, but it definitely delivers more features. This product is a little different from the others as it is a coil mattress. It features 204 premium coils for ideal firmness. The coils are covered with a light foam layer for comfort and contour. It’s dual-sided, with a firmer side for a newborn and a softer side for a toddler. The cover is made of cotton. The inside is covered with a waterproof layer to block moisture from getting inside the mattress. This mattress is, of course, Greenguard Gold certified, so it is safe for all newborns to sleep on.
Features
- Coil mattress – 204 premium coils
- Dual-sided firmness
- Waterproof
- Greenguard Gold Certified
Information
5. Kolcraft Pure Sleep Toddler and Baby Crib Mattress
For Amazon Prime Members, this is the most affordable option. This mattress offers extra firm support, with 150 steel coils. It features a waterproof and stain-resistant cover. The mattress is Greenguard Gold certified. Like the other options, it does not contain toxic fire retardants. It’s made in the USA and fits most standard crib sizes.
Features
- 150 steel coils
- Waterproof/stainproof cover
- Greenguard Gold Certified
Information
Recommended for you
Top 10 Mattresses to use in pregnancy
Patricia
September 20, 2026
No Comments
Sleep Tips for Night Shift Workers
5 tips for choosing your new bed
5 Best Mattresses For Hip Pain in 2026
Nadia Whitfield
Nadia Whitfield is TalkBeds' Sleep Science Editor. A sleep researcher and science writer by background, she is the reason our sleep and health claims can be trusted. While our testers focus on how a mattress feels, Nadia focuses on what the evidence… Full profile & sources →
