Newborn babies spend more time sleeping then they do awake (even though it may not always seem this way)! It’s for this reason that you want to give them a safe, comfortable bed they’ll enjoy. Choosing the right mattress for your baby’s crib can be difficult with all the endless options you have online, but we are here to narrow down the search selection for you with the best mattresses for cribs in 2026:
The Naturepedic Organic Cotton is one of our top picks because of its luxurious, organic material. Your little one will love its soft feel, and you as a parent will be at ease knowing your baby is asleep on safe materials. It’s also waterproof and stain-resistant, making it very easy to clean.
The Newton Baby Crib Mattress has everything a parent hopes for in a crib mattress – safety, comfort, and durability! The breathable fabric reduces the risk of suffocation especially as your baby begins to roll over. It also regulates temperature, keeping your baby comfortable and improving the quality of their sleep.
You will love this dual-sided mattress made from eco-friendly materials. One side is very firm while the other side is more for toddlers who enjoy softer beds. Not only is the Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer a safe and comfortable selection, but it saves parents money long-term since they’ll be able to use it as their little one grows.
Newborn babies spend more time sleeping then they do awake (even though it may not always seem this way)! It’s for this reason that you want to give them a safe, comfortable bed they’ll enjoy. Choosing the right mattress for your baby’s crib can be difficult with all the endless options you have online, but we are here to narrow down the search selection for you with the best mattresses for cribs in 2026:
Since its inception in 1955, Colgate has crafted some remarkable mattresses, and this one ranks among their best. This crib mattress stands out with its eco-friendly credentials, ditching vinyl for an organic cover. It boasts a dual-sided feature, with a softer side designed for toddlers and a harder side suitable for infants. This is a fantastic cost-effective solution that adjusts to your baby’s growth!
The Emily Natural mattress offers a high-quality mattress with organic materials. Certified by GREENGUARD Gold, you can rest assured that it’s completely safe for your little one. Made in the USA, this mattress has it all – comfort, safety, and great ventilation so your baby doesn’t get sweaty while they sleep. The only downfall is that mattress covers for this selection are sold separately.
This brings us to the end of our crib mattress guide. We guarantee that any of these selections are worth your money and will keep your little one comfortable and safe. Firm, waterproof, and durable, you can’t go wrong with these hot picks!
Nadia Whitfield
Nadia Whitfield is TalkBeds' Sleep Science Editor. A sleep researcher and science writer by background, she is the reason our sleep and health claims can be trusted. While our testers focus on how a mattress feels, Nadia focuses on what the evidence… Full profile & sources →
